Posted By Gibs at 09:45 AM - Thu Mar 15 2018
you are the guy i want to talk to. I am ok with The Waerd but there are some things I dont like about them like the whole giving your things to other people. If I have a sword and someone says I like that give it to me. are we the player to say ok? thats silly. But the RPG element for them is so much fun
It's more of a community thing. "If I have a sword"; you would never have a sword to begin with. If you need a sword, you would take it from the community pool of weapons. No one should be asking for the weapon that you are using unless the pool of weapons has been expended, in which case the issue is more that whoever makes weapons hasn't made enough or the people who provide materials to the weapon maker's aren't providing enough materials. A piece of the system is broken and needs to be fixed.
The main issue that I have with this sort of community is the trust factor. There is pretty much nothing to prevent someone from abusing the system, stealing everything, and selling it in a nearby town for their own gain. Granted, if that was the case, then it is likely that that person would be caste out of the system, but that punishment doesn't replace the stolen goods.
The positive side is that, with it being very community driven, the level of teamwork and lack of division will make for a very formidable enemy.
It is an interesting society and I look forward to seeing examples of it "working"; but it will be an unusual existence for some people, for sure.